This article highlights insights from Billy from Newton Makes, a woodworking creator known for clear, practical advice. This article covers the key differences between thickness planers and drum sanders, helping woodworkers decide which tool best fits their needs.
Both machines play important roles in preparing lumber, but they excel in different areas. Understanding their strengths and limitations will help you make smarter purchasing decisions for your workshop.
Watch the full video and subscribe to Billy’s channel:
What a Thickness Planer Does Best
The thickness planer is designed to flatten boards and bring them down to a consistent thickness. Using high-speed spinning blades, it removes material quickly, making it ideal for milling rough lumber or resizing stock.
Speed is one of the thickness planer’s biggest advantages. It can remove large amounts of material fast, turning rough-sawn wood into usable boards in just a few passes.
Key Features of a Thickness Planer
Most thickness planers include a height adjustment mechanism to set your desired board thickness. Some models use traditional straight knives, while higher-end versions feature helical heads for smoother cutting.
Built-in thickness gauges help monitor material removal, though manual measuring with a combination square can offer better accuracy. Planer capacity typically limits the maximum width you can process, with common models handling around 12 to 13 inches.
Common Applications for Thickness Planers
Thickness planers are perfect for dimensioning lumber after jointing one face. They create parallel faces, which are critical for accurate joinery and finishing.
However, figured woods or thin stock can cause problems in a planer. The aggressive cutting action can easily lead to tear-out, especially when grain direction changes unexpectedly.
Why a Drum Sander May Be the Better Choice
The drum sander addresses some of the planer’s shortcomings. Rather than cutting, it sands the surface with a rotating drum wrapped in abrasive paper, allowing for much more delicate material removal.
This makes the drum sander perfect for final thickness adjustments, especially on thin boards or highly figured wood. It minimizes the risk of tear-out while providing a smooth, even surface.
Features That Set the Drum Sander Apart
Like planers, drum sanders feature adjustable heights to control material thickness. Many models allow you to sand extra-wide boards by flipping them around, thanks to open-ended designs.
Fine-tuning is where drum sanders really shine. Small thickness changes are easy to manage, and there’s far less risk of damaging the wood’s surface during the process.
When a Drum Sander Is the Better Choice
Projects like cutting boards, fine furniture panels, or veneered surfaces benefit greatly from a drum sander. The gentle action ensures that grain patterns stay intact and surfaces remain blemish-free.
Additionally, the drum sander is perfect for small adjustments when fitting pieces into a tight space. If absolute precision is your goal, the drum sander offers a level of control that the thickness planer can’t match.
Drawbacks to Consider
No tool is perfect, and both the thickness planer and drum sander have their downsides. Planers are loud, aggressive, and can sometimes tear apart delicate boards if not used carefully.
Drum sanders, on the other hand, are slow when removing large amounts of material. They also produce a significant amount of fine dust, which requires strong dust collection to manage effectively.
Using Both Tools Together for Best Results
Many experienced woodworkers, including Billy, recommend using both tools as part of a larger process. Start by removing most of the material with the planer to save time.
Once the board is close to its final thickness, transition to the drum sander. This two-step approach balances speed with precision and dramatically reduces the risk of tear-out or surface defects.
Which Tool Should You Get First?
Choosing between the two tools comes down to the type of work you do most often. If your projects involve rough lumber, heavy milling, or furniture construction, a thickness planer is the more critical investment.
If you frequently work with intricate designs, cutting boards, or figured woods, a drum sander might be more beneficial to start with. Ideally, both tools together offer the best workflow for most woodworking shops.
Final Thoughts
Thickness planers and drum sanders each fill an important role, but they aren’t interchangeable. A planer provides fast material removal, while a drum sander refines surfaces with minimal risk to the wood.
Billy’s advice highlights how understanding your tools leads to better project outcomes. Whether you’re investing in your first major machine or expanding your shop’s capabilities, knowing when and how to use each tool makes all the difference.
Please support Billy by visiting his website here: https://www.newtonmakes.com/shop.