The video “2×4 Box vs Walnut Box – What’s Worth More? Wood Box SHOOTOUT!” is by Newton Makes. In this engaging exploration, Billy dives into the world of woodworking and challenges the perception of value based on materials used. The project centers on making two identical wooden boxes, one from construction lumber and the other from walnut, to assess their worth.
Billy shares his journey, recounting how a previous video on fine woodworking with 2×4 construction lumber stirred quite a reaction. Many viewers were quick to dismiss the quality of the boxes simply because they were made from 2x4s, leading to a heated discussion about craftsmanship and material value.
To address this, he decided to create a case study comparing two boxes to see if the material truly dictates their worth.
Starting with the materials, Billy rummaged through his shop and found some well-dried construction lumber, estimating it would cost about five dollars for the box. In contrast, he selected a walnut board, which he estimated would set him back around fifteen dollars for the walnut box.
This price difference sparked the question: does the material really make that much difference in perceived value?
With the materials sorted, Billy meticulously cut the pieces for both boxes, ensuring they were identical in size and shape. He opted for box joints, which he finds visually appealing, and set up his sled with a taller auxiliary fence to accommodate the larger pieces.
After cutting the joints, Billy moved on to the tops and bottoms of the boxes. Instead of using the table saw to cut grooves, which would leave unsightly notches, he decided to use the router table for a cleaner plunge cut. This attention to detail exemplifies Billy’s commitment to quality craftsmanship.
Once the bottoms were ready, he dry assembled the pieces and was pleased with how they fit together. While the glue dried, he began working on the lids, ensuring they were both functional and aesthetically pleasing. He even added a little feature to make it easier to pull the lid in and out.
After sanding both boxes down to a lovely 180 grit, the excitement built up as he prepared to apply the finish. Billy prefers to keep it simple with a hard wax finish, which he feels complements both materials beautifully.
Now comes the moment of truth: the comparison. With both boxes built with the same care and attention, the only difference was the material. Billy speculates that most people would lean towards the walnut box for its rich appearance, while the construction lumber box, despite being well-crafted, might not receive the same appreciation.
Billy challenges the notion that the construction lumber box should be valued at only five dollars. Based on his experience selling boxes, he believes both boxes are worth more than their material cost suggests. He even shares that he successfully sold two boxes made from pine for thirty dollars each, proving that craftsmanship can shine through regardless of the material.
The key takeaway from this wood box shootout is the subjective nature of value in woodworking. Billy emphasizes that while some may only see the material, many appreciate the skill and craftsmanship involved in creating something beautiful. He encourages aspiring woodworkers not to be deterred by the type of lumber they can afford, as it’s the effort and creativity that truly matter.
“What’s really important is that we all get into our shops, try to make something cool, and try to improve our skills.” – Newton Makes
In conclusion, Newton Makes reminds everyone that whether using high-end walnut or humble 2x4s, the heart of woodworking lies in the creativity and craftsmanship behind each project. So get out there, embrace your materials, and build something awesome!